Search This Blog

Friday, March 13, 2020

Dethronement of Sarki: Is it worth the fuss?


(Link on Daily Trust site)


As a barely interested observer following the dramatic developments of the dethronement and subsequent banishment of the former Sarkin Kano Muhammadu Sunusi ll, from afar, I am basically more interested in the implications of the sheer emotions that characterize the ensuing controversy.

As a son of the soil raised within a walkable distance from the historic Gidan Sarki Palace in Kano metropolis, the grandeur and glamour that the traditional Sarauta institution represents, and indeed the legendary mystery surrounding it explained my huge admiration of it. 

Also, the narratives about its ancient roots and its subsequent transformation among other traditional institutions into one of the major emirates within the Sheikh Usman bin Fodio-founded Caliphate in the 18th century explained the enormous respect one has always had for it. This is though with the incremental exposure and experience inherent in the process of one’s growth into maturity, and indeed the little knowledge one has acquired over the period, one was able to grow beyond naive glorification of the institution, which had, after all, already been rendered mere ceremonial. 

To arrive at that conclusion, I had reasoned that if the systematic tyranny and brutality that the post-Caliphate British-imposed and retained emirs perpetrated against their respective people on behalf of the British colonial officers had been committed elsewhere, their subsequent departure in 1960 would have, at least, ushered in the end of the relevance of the traditional institutions in public affairs. 

Though towards the independence, there had been a considerable rise in the public consciousness of their rights, thanks to the efforts of Mallam Aminu Kano and other like-minded populist politicians who fearlessly challenged the status quo, yet since the independence, there has been no commitment whatsoever to addressing the physiological trauma, let alone the physical suffering and losses that such traditional institutions had systematically inflicted on millions of vulnerable people in various domains across northern Nigeria. 

Besides, there has been no proper documentation of the victims’ horrible experiences even though from the verbal accounts of some among the aged population of the surviving victims, their plight was miserable enough to be compared to the plight of the Bilals of the early years of Islam in Makkah. In fact, not even an apology has ever been deemed appropriate for the surviving victims of such feudal atrocities. Whereas, if it had been in some ultra-leftist revolutionary societies like Mao-Tse-tung’s China, the perpetrators, their cronies and other beneficiaries of their reigns of cruelty would have faced spontaneous massacres at the hands of the vengeful public.

Also, contrary to the claim that traditional emirate institutions are apolitical and should, therefore, be treated accordingly, the reality is that, all along and since the British conquest of the Caliphate, and the subsequent successive civilian administrations and military regimes in the country, the creation of traditional emirates, the appointment of emirs, and the policies of the emirate institutions have always been subject to the political interests of the political leadership in the relevant domain and/or at the national level. 

It has always been a mutually beneficial relationship between politicians who have always manipulated the moral influence of the emirs to win elections under a democratic dispensation, and secure public confidence and approval under military dictatorship. In return, it’s an open secret that a typical emir or traditional title holder enjoys undue government privileges, which he largely abuses in the systematic facilitation of nepotism and impunity in favour of his cronies and indeed the highest bidder for his services. 

Besides, primitive and superstitious practices, heretical rituals and protocols most of which contradict the basic tenets of Islam have replaced the Islamic teachings on which Sheikh ibn Fodio founded the emirate institutions. Generational slaveholding and concubine-keeping against successive generations of families whose free-born ancestors were unjustifiably acquired as slaves over the centuries are still common in the institutions.   

Also, greeting protocols in the institutions where people literally prostrate before the emir amid ego-massaging and pride-inducing medieval hyperbolic praises showered on him by praisers, aren’t only absolutely unIslamic, but also represent some of the crudest manifestations of primitive but institutionalized human degradation. 

By the way, and as I have always observed, such are the practices that the former Sarkin Kano, as a reformer, should have challenged to reform the institution and restore its original Islamic identity.   

Interestingly, the gradual derailment of the emirate institutions had begun long before the British conquest; in fact, it started almost immediately after the demise of their founder, Sheikh Usman ibn Fodio and many of his close companions. His surviving brother then and the Emir of Gwandu, Sheikh Abdullahi ibn Fodio, lamented the situation in a beautifully composed poem in Arabic where he lamented that “After the successive demise of my companions, (i.e. his brother and some other Jihad leaders who were emirs of various domains), I have been rendered hopeless amid charlatans (referring to the succeeding generation of emirs then). 

In the poem, Sheikh Abdullahi ibn Fodio castigated them for “preaching what they never practice, and performing their duties poorly”. He also described them as “grossly unlearned who, however, never seek knowledge, with everyone simply claiming superior arguments on issues”. Lamenting further, the Sheikh continued, “they abuse kinship, insult friends and are hell-bent on wealth accumulation; also neither mosques nor schools, let alone Jihad constitutes a matter of importance to them anymore; their obsession instead revolves around rulership over domains and people to enjoy the attendant pleasure and prestige, as well as the accumulation of concubines, fashionable attires and beautiful horses for showing off in cities, not for Jihad. As they are also obsessed with inducement gifts, booty, bribe and praises of praise-singers”     
    
Anyway, while emirate traditional institutions deserve respect anyway, it should be only to the extent of their commitment to the Islamic tenets and practices on which they were founded. Also, as an institution that supposedly represents our value system, which is based and subject to the Islamic religion, there should be an effective mechanism in place to push for its reformation accordingly, and indeed hold it to account.  

Meanwhile, the recent dethronement of Sarkin Kano is not worth all that fuss. 

Friday, February 28, 2020

Can Boko Haramists be deradicalized?

(Link on Daily Trust site)



A bill for the establishment of a commission for “rehabilitating, de-radicalizing, and reintegrating the defectors, repentant and forcefully conscripted members of the insurgent group Boko Haram to make them useful members of the society” as explained by its sponsor, senator Ibrahim Gaidam of Yobe East has generated controversy.   
Countries grappling with insurgency and other forms of organized terrorism tend to introduce programs to rehabilitate captured and surrendered elements involved in such crimes to prepare them for successful reintegration into society through a structured process of psychological reform, deradicalization, attitudinal change, and economic empowerment. An affected country’s prospect of success depends on the extent of its understanding of the underlying dynamics of its peculiar situation, and indeed its ability to come up with appropriate deradicalization and rehabilitation strategy.
A standard deradicalization program is always limited in scope and period; it’s designed in such a way that it only benefits those who deserve it who are also usually relatively very few. In other words, it’s meant for those who terrorist recruiters had capitalized on their naivety and recruited them through misleading ideological indoctrination and physiological manipulation. They are largely identified among the rank and file of ideologically-motivated terror groups like Boko Haram. They are rarely found among solely greed-driven criminal groups like bandits and kidnappers.
Basically, all captured subversive elements should always be subjected to applicable criminal investigations and judicial trials to determine their respective guilt or innocence, and be treated accordingly. After all, the convicted who should face either execution, life imprisonment or extended jail terms, are automatically excluded from any deradicalization program with a view to releasing them.
Now, over the past few years, Nigerian authorities have released hundreds of the so-called repentant Boko Haram fighters said to have been deradicalized and rehabilitated. Yet, a controversial move has now been initiated at the Senate to establish a whole substantive commission ostensibly for this purpose. 
Regardless of the reliability or otherwise of the deradicalization process through which those “repentant” Boko Haram fighters were released, a move to establish such commission is not only unnecessary but also insensitive to the feelings of the millions of innocent Nigerians rendered miserable as a result of the terror activities of the very terrorists being released under this questionable program. Besides, it was, and in fact, it’s still, too early, in the first place, to embark on releasing the captured terrorists while their fellow terrorists are still out there massacring defenceless Nigerians, displacing thousands, and unleashing misery in the country.  
That move also suggests a tacit and certainly unjustifiable presumption that the Boko Haram insurgency and other major security challenges in the country are here to stay hence the need to establish a whole commission to embark on a vicious circle of rehabilitating captured and surrendered insurgents and bandits. And, of course, when established, the commission would end up as another source of stealing public resources in the name of rehabilitation and deradicalization of captured terrorists and other criminals. By the way, though one’s unawareness of the existence of something never means its absence, arguably there is no such a commission even among the worst insurgency-hit countries in the world. 
Anyway, while captured Boko Haram terrorists can indeed be deradicalized and rehabilitated to become law-abiding and productive citizens, the obvious incompetence on the part of the relevant Nigerian authorities doesn’t only undermine the program but also renders it counterproductive for that matter.
Nigerian authorities should immediately suspend this program to review the process of identifying the eligible candidates for deradicalization, rehabilitation and release among the captured and surrendered terrorists, in light of the arguments highlighted herein. This has to be part of a comprehensive policy that guarantees the achievement of the intended purpose.  
A painstaking vetting process should be put in place to identify the eligible candidates because obviously every captured terrorist or bandit will claim repentance and pretend accordingly to get away with his crime and get released.
Also, with regard to the captured members of the Boko Haram group and other like-minded groups found eligible for deradicalization and rehabilitation for possible release, Nigerian authorities should engage the services of reputable Islamic scholars in the process. Because such elements are under the illusion that they are right and that what they are doing is according to Islamic teachings. Also, having imbibed a lot of grossly misrepresented meanings of some Qur’anic verses, Prophetic hadiths and jurists’ opinions, which they vehemently cling to, they can discard those illusions only when overwhelmed with superior arguments on the correct meanings of those Qur’anic verses, hadiths and jurists’ views.
To achieve this, a relaxed but regulated environment should be provided for regular seasons of this engagement with the candidates over a reasonable period at the end of which the authorities should be guided by the recommendations of those scholars on determining whether a particular candidate is deradicalized or not. After all, spiritual guidance is exclusively Allah’s Who gives it to whom He wishes.

Friday, February 14, 2020

AU Summit: Between Buhari’s and El-Sisi’s speeches

(Link on Daily Trust site)



Though to a much lesser degree compared to Nigeria, Egypt struggles with terror-related security challenges. However, apart from the military dimension of their respective struggles, there is practically no other basis of comparison between the two countries’ approaches in this regard. Because while Egypt’s approach suggests a realistic understanding of the underlying politics of handling such type of security crisis, Nigeria’s suggests gross and indeed inexcusable naivety. 

Of course, this explains why while Egypt has been able to keep its security challenges largely contained, Nigeria appears to have exhausted all its military and intelligence capabilities to no avail as the wave of indiscriminate massacre of people, banditry, kidnapping armed robbery and other organized crimes continues to unleash misery across the country and indeed threatens its very survival.

While President Muhammadu Buhari of Nigeria inadvertently betrayed that naivety in his speech during the African Union Peace and Security Council on the state of peace and security in Africa at the recently concluded 33rd AU summit in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, his Egyptian counterpart, Abdul-Fattah El-Sisi, displayed such realistic understanding in his speech. For instance, in his speech, El-Sisi called for the formation of an African anti-terror military command; and even offered to host an African summit in Cairo for that purpose; and indeed tacitly offered to host the command headquarters in Cairo as well, claiming that his call and offer were out of Egypt’s sense of responsibility and commitment to maintaining peace and security in Africa. 

However, while he indeed sounded committed to African security project, he was actually never that interested in African interests; after all, though Egypt is a major African country, its interest in African affairs, which climaxed during the era of President Jamal Abdun-Nasir, began to decline following his resignation in 1967 and has been on a decline ever since then.

President El-Sisi, therefore, was in reality only trying to mobilize and manipulate African military, diplomatic and intelligence resources in his country’s struggle to maintain control over its porous desert borders with Libya, which facilitate the movement of armed groups and weapons into Egypt that fuels terror activities in the country. He also seeks to manipulate the sheer diplomatic weight necessarily associated with a continental military alliance of such size to gain the diplomatic advantage over Egypt’s rivals, especially Turkey and Qatar, in their struggle for influence in shaping the Libyan political destiny and direction. 

Of course, if President El-Sisi decides to follow through with his plan, he will almost certainly achieve his agenda while Nigeria and other member countries struggling with existential security challenges remain constrained by their simplistic approach to the complexities of international politics of interests among countries.

On his part, however, President Buhari only called on the member-countries of the AU to “look for new strategies that would be helpful in effectively preventing, managing and resolving conflicts on the continent.” He also maintained that “trends and emerging challenges on the continent call for a better approach to resolving conflicts.  He, therefore, “called on the AU to strengthen its own mediation tools and develop a new intervention road map that would promote national dialogue, reconciliation and social cohesion.”

By the way, this line of thought has always been the fundamental feature of Nigerian leaders’ and diplomats’ speeches in this regard in various international events since the eruption of the Boko Haram insurgency a decade ago. They have always sounded helpless apparently to attract the sympathy of the international community in hopes of attracting its commitment to assisting in ending the terror insurgency in the country.

As I observed in a previous article, Nigerian leaders’  “approach to diplomacy has always suggested inexcusable cluelessness of the simple fact that that the real business of diplomacy is, in reality, practised contrary to what the relevant theories contained in academic books teach. They have acted as though oblivious of the fact that in diplomacy nothing is given or achieved for free, hence a country’s ability to get what it wants or secure its interest in a bilateral or multilateral engagement depends on its ability to deploy and leverage whatever coercive or persuasive tools it possesses to extort compromises and concessions from the party (ies), and/or entice them with tempting incentives.” (Nigeria’s toothless diplomacy, Daily Trust, Friday, September 13, 2019).

Anyway, while President Buhari’s speech has almost certainly been archived in the AU’s archives, Egypt is almost certainly already working towards achieving its actual interests, which are cleverly disguised in President El-Sisi’s purported solidarity speech.  

Besides, while diplomatic engagements do indeed enable countries to achieve their legitimate and even illegitimate interests, it takes more than official visits, attending international events and pity-arousing rhetoric to get real benefits from those engagements. Therefore, as I recommended elsewhere, “…the federal government should, for a start, identify its potential, assets, circumstances and whatever can be used as an advantageous tool to push for appropriate global recognition of its war against Boko Haram as a war that the world simply can’t afford to ignore. This is quite achievable by, for instance, engaging relevant leading international consulting firms, international pressure groups and influential lobby groups with unhindered access to the corridors of, say, the Capitol Hill and the White House in Washington, the Palace of Westminster and 10 Downing Street in London, the Ã‰lysée Palace in Paris and the European diplomatic and military institutions headquartered in Brussels, to pursue this agenda on behalf of the federal government. (Impedimentto decisive victory over Boko Haram, Daily Trust, Friday, November 30, 2018).     

One wonders how on earth these basic facts and measures elude Nigerian foreign policymakers and diplomats, as also one wonders what the Nigerian Institute of International Affairs (NIIA) and the National Institute for Policy and Strategic Studies (NIPSS) and other relevant institutions do exactly produce in terms of policy recommendations to guide the country’s foreign policy and diplomatic engagements. 

Friday, January 24, 2020

State police: Between necessity and worries


(Link on Daily Trust site)


The apparent incapability of the Nigerian police to stop the persistent deterioration of the security situation in Nigeria, on the one hand, and the justifiable worries over the implications of sanctioning the creation of state police or armed security outfits in a fragile federal state like Nigeria, on the other, represent a dilemma that requires a collective sense of responsibility to address without prejudice to the bases of the country’s corporate existence.

This is particularly necessary now that the six South-west states have launched a   sub-regional security outfit named Amotekun without enabling laws, which they, in the first place, lack the jurisdiction to make, thereby prompting the raging controversy. Also, though the federal government has declared the outfit illegal, the governors behind it aren’t likely to comply.

This development is also likely to encourage other governors or geopolitical zones to follow suit; after all, advocates of “true federalism” have always advocated enabling legislation for the creation of state police to complement the federal police. They have always argued, among other things, that it’s one of the basic characteristics of the American-style federalism that Nigeria ostensibly practices.  

However, northern Nigerian establishment has always been against it on account of deep-rooted worries that it may undermine and jeopardize the country’s corporate survival, which the region particularly considers non-negotiable.

Besides, there are understandable worries that against the backdrop of the recurrent outbreak of ethnoreligious conflicts in the country, state police, more so state security outfits could be manipulated in the intimidation and victimization of vulnerable communities living in states other than their respective native states. After all, over the decades, there have been so many instances across the country whereby indigenous armed groups would carry out heinous atrocities against communities on account of their regional and ethnoreligious backgrounds. Massacres and counter-massacres have been committed, which left irreparable scars in the minds of millions of Nigerians.

There are worries also that it may trigger a vicious circle of victimization, vendetta and vengeance among various ethnoreligious groups in the country. Because whenever a particular ethnoreligious community suffers victimization at the hands of an indigenous armed security outfit in a state or a geopolitical zone, the perpetrators’ ethnoreligious compatriots living in the victims’ native state(s) would be automatically exposed to imminent retaliatory victimization at the hands of the indigenous armed security outfits there, which may result in pervasive chaos that may indeed escalate into uncontrollable ethnoreligious conflicts across the country. Already, there have been many instances of this scenario involving many, if not most, states in the country.  
    
Critics of this idea also warn that state police or armed security outfits are likely to end up as tools in the hands of state governors and other politicians to perpetrate politically-motivated intimidation and persecution against their political opponents. Politicians, after all, already sponsor armed thugs who intimidate and perpetrate violence against the electorate, election officials and, of course, their rival armed thugs to effectively grab election victory for their respective sponsors.  

Northern Nigerian establishment is particularly obsessed with those worries, which explains its uncompromising obsession with Nigeria’s corporate existence. Interestingly, however, what most northern Nigerian elites don’t want to publicly admit is that the underlying motive of this obsession is the fear that the region may not survive the cessation of the inflow of crude oil proceeds, which automatically stop in the event of the country’s disintegration. This is notwithstanding the region’s immeasurable agricultural and crude oil reserves potential, for it requires massive investment and indeed takes time to develop into economy-sustaining resources.

Anyway, now that the South-west states have created an armed security outfit for their geopolitical zone presumably to complement the police, which generated the current controversy, there’s no better time than now to address the issue decisively. Because, among other things, while the federal government lacks effective enforcement instruments to enforce its ban on the outfit, other zones and states are likely to equally launch their respective security outfits soon. And unless constitutionally sanctioned and regulated, the trend may lead to the proliferation of armed security outfits with serious security implications that the country cannot afford. 

This is also absolutely urgent in the face of the alarming worsening of the security situation in the country as the atrocious activities perpetrated by bandits, kidnappers, terrorists, armed robbers and other crime syndicates steadily overwhelm the already grossly understaffed, under-equipped, exhausted and largely demoralized Nigerian police personnel.

Though it’s indeed a tricky dilemma, yet it can be addressed, only that it takes a sense of responsibility and an imaginative approach on the part of those in the positions of authority to provide appropriate constitutional provisions that not only sanction the creation of standard police in states or geopolitical zones but also address all the underlying worries surrounding it.

Effective federally-regulated supervisory mechanisms should also be put in place to ensure strict compliance with the standard professional policing practices and ethics that translate into efficient mutually complementing policing between the federal and the state police.   

Friday, January 17, 2020

The myth of Iran-Saudi power struggle

(Link on Daily Trust site)




There is a popular but simplistic assumption especially among Nigerians interested in the Middle East politics that Iran and Saudi Arabia are locked in a protracted geopolitical power struggle. This is obvious from most of the analyses churned out by both the presumably well-informed observers and the barely informed media audience who, either due to language constraints or limited means, cannot access sufficient amount of relevant information and exhaustive analyses on the topic and the region’s geopolitics at large.

However, contrary to that assumption, the forty-year-old tensions between Iran and Saudi Arabia are never linked to any geopolitical power struggle. After all, a geopolitical power struggle necessarily involves two or more regional countries with expansionist ambitions and locked in a struggle for regional supremacy at the expense of one another.